Thursday, May 31, 2007
A Medical No-Fly List?
Responding to the case of Andrew Speaker -- the carrier of drug-resistant TB who flew on an intercontinental jet and potentially infected fellow passengers from all over the world, Cecilia writes:
The Atlanta lawyer who went to Europe for his wedding and honeymoon despite knowing he had drug-resistant tuberculosis and having been told not to travel is a selfish idiot. I'm sure having to postpone his wedding and honeymoon would have been a hassle, but now a lot of people might be infected, including his wife! TB is a serious illness, it's not something minor like a cold from which people recover after a few days. People could die as a result of his actions.
It's hard to disagree. We have an (admittedly faulty) TSA No-Fly list for potential terrorists, so a Medical No-Fly list is the next logical step in protecting ourselves. Indeed, the attacks of 9/11 may end up making it easier to institute such a No-Fly list because the political fight to keep certain individuals from flying has already been won.
As has been said before:
Rule #1: Super-empowered individuals may rule vertical scenarios, but nation-states still rule horizontal scenarios.
In other words: individuals are able to do great damage in a short amount of time. But countries do great good over long periods of time.
Osama bin Laden and Andrew Speaker are both super-empowered individuals who exploited the modern world to achive their goals, and ended creating outrage. Yet by exposing problems to solutions, they end up making the system more safe and secure than it was before.
15:14 Posted in Health Care, Thomas Barnett | Permalink | Comments (7) | Email this | Tags: horizontal scenarios, andrew speaker, tb, no-fly list