Friday, May 06, 2005
Full Spectrum Politics (Generations of Pre-Modern and Modern Politics)
"Technology Solutions for a Full Spectrum Force: Agile Development," by Tom Stautz, Armaments for Full Spectrum Warfare Conference & Exhibition, 25 June 2003, http://www.dtic.mil/ndia/2003armaments/1130.ppt.
Colonel Stauz's presentation for the Armaments for FSW define full spectrum dominance as
The ability of US forces, operating unilaterally or in combination with multinational and inter-agency partners, to defeat any adversary and control any situation across the full range of military operations.
This can be reworked to define political full spectrum dominance as
The ability of forces, operating alone or with others, to defeat any collection of adversaries and define any issue across the full range of political operations
"Spectrum" is a reference to the color spectrum. Think of the different generations of politics like a color line, with earlier phases running into later ones
Five "colors" are shown here
- Pre-Modern Politics (PMP)
- First Generation of Modern Politics (1GP)
- Second Generation of Modern Politics (2GP)
- Third Generation of Modern Politics (3GP)
- Fourth Generation of Modern Politics (4GP)
PMP is sometimes not included because it is barely politics as we recognize it. Unlike modern politics it is not organized for a belief, ideology, party, or even candidate -- there is no "point" to a PMP network other than the PMP network itself. PMP networks are familial networks, The only way to directly increase a familial network is to increase the number of children, though "permanent" alliances can be forged with other nets through marriages.
PMP networks are very steep, and appear to be timeless.
First Generation of Modern Politics
1GP is sometimes called the "mass line" or the "spoils system." 1GP nets often triumphed over PMP nets because 1GP nets scale quickly. The head of the net takes resources ("spoils") from the government to give to his subordinates, who in turn have their own spoiled subordinates, and so on.
1GP networks, sensing that the "vanquished" PMP nets may be biding their time, often attempt to destroy PGPS. This reached its most extreme form in Pol Pot's Cambodia, where an immediate and explicit program of family disintegration was instituted. China and the Catholic Church used offspring restrictions to achieve the same goals less violently.
1GP networks are slightly less steep than PMP nets. While 1GP governments are ancient (Exodus clearly describes a ruling 1GP net built by Moses), 1GP nets with "political program" were introduced to the United State by Andrew Jackson.
Second Generation of Modern Politics
2GP is media based. Dramatically cutting the costs associated with a spoils system, 2GP nets use relatively inexpensive voters to talk to the people directly. In 2GP, the people are convinced they will get something out of the politician directly, instead of having to go through a corrupt intermediary.
2GP is both more and less steep than 1GP. It is less steep because the people are on the same level as each other, and there are fewer intermediaries between the politician and the people. But the politician is still as vital as ever. Think of 1GP as a mountain gradually descending into a valley, and 2GP of a mountain, a sheer cliff face, and the valley below.
Franklin Roosevelt's "fireside chats" showed the power of 2GP in America.
Third Generation of Modern Politics
Because it's based on maneuver, the chart is a bit confusing. Hold on
2GP required new technologies (media) to cut costs. 3GP uses no new technology. 2GP won because 2GP nets scale bigger, cheaper than 1GP networks. 3GP nets are much smaller. 3GP is a bridge between organization-based earlier earlier generations of politics and the ideological-networked Fourth Generation.
Small 3GP networks can beat big 2GP nets because 3GP organizations are fast. They "get inside the enemy's decision loop," paralyzing the opponent and making the enemy's mistake compound on mistake. However, self-synchronization is vital in Third Generation Politics. Maneuver without coordination is "flip-flopping," as Senator Kerry discovered to his memory.
The greatest practitioner of 3GP in American history is President Clinton.
Fourth Generation of Modern Politics
Exhaustively covered before. Much of tdaxp :: Doctrine is now dedicated to the concept.
Are any organizations now geared to politic Full Spectrum -- to "outshine" in every "color"? What happens to successful FSP movements when they vanquish their enemies? Those are posts for other times...